You are at netAirspace : Forum : The Combustion Chamber - Off-Topics : General Off-Topics

Chips in official IDs raise privacy fears

Everything that would not belong anywhere else.
 

Airfoilsguy (Founding Member) 02 Aug 09, 20:38Post
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20090711/ap_ ... america_iv


Nice of this guy to explain how to do it so others may learn.


Climbing into his Volvo, outfitted with a Matrics antenna and a Motorola reader he'd bought on eBay for $190, Chris Paget cruised the streets of San Francisco with this objective: To read the identity cards of strangers, wirelessly, without ever leaving his car.

It took him 20 minutes to strike hacker's gold.

Zipping past Fisherman's Wharf, his scanner detected, then downloaded to his laptop, the unique serial numbers of two pedestrians' electronic U.S. passport cards embedded with radio frequency identification, or RFID, tags. Within an hour, he'd "skimmed" the identifiers of four more of the new, microchipped PASS cards from a distance of 20 feet.

Embedding identity documents — passports, drivers licenses, and the like — with RFID chips is a no-brainer to government officials. Increasingly, they are promoting it as a 21st century application of technology that will help speed border crossings, safeguard credentials against counterfeiters, and keep terrorists from sneaking into the country.

But Paget's February experiment demonstrated something privacy advocates had feared for years: That RFID, coupled with other technologies, could make people trackable without their knowledge or consent.

He filmed his drive-by heist, and soon his video went viral on the Web, intensifying a debate over a push by government, federal and state, to put tracking technologies in identity documents and over their potential to erode privacy.

Putting a traceable RFID in every pocket has the potential to make everybody a blip on someone's radar screen, critics say, and to redefine Orwellian government snooping for the digital age.

"Little Brother," some are already calling it — even though elements of the global surveillance web they warn against exist only on drawing boards, neither available nor approved for use.

But with advances in tracking technologies coming at an ever-faster rate, critics say, it won't be long before governments could be able to identify and track anyone in real time, 24-7, from a cafe in Paris to the shores of California.

The key to getting such a system to work, these opponents say, is making sure everyone carries an RFID tag linked to a biometric data file.

On June 1, it became mandatory for Americans entering the United States by land or sea from Canada, Mexico, Bermuda and the Caribbean to present identity documents embedded with RFID tags, though conventional passports remain valid until they expire.

Among new options are the chipped "e-passport," and the new, electronic PASS card — credit-card sized, with the bearer's digital photograph and a chip that can be scanned through a pocket, backpack or purse from 30 feet.

Alternatively, travelers can use "enhanced" driver's licenses embedded with RFID tags now being issued in some border states: Washington, Vermont, Michigan and New York. Texas and Arizona have entered into agreements with the federal government to offer chipped licenses, and the U.S. Department of Homeland Security has recommended expansion to non-border states. Kansas and Florida officials have received DHS briefings on the licenses, agency records show.

The purpose of using RFID is not to identify people, says Mary Ellen Callahan, the chief privacy officer at Homeland Security, but rather "to verify that the identification document holds valid information about you."

Likewise, U.S. border agents are "pinging" databases only to confirm that licenses aren't counterfeited. "They're not pulling up your speeding tickets," she says, or looking at personal information beyond what is on a passport.

The change is largely about speed and convenience, she says. An RFID document that doubles as a U.S. travel credential "only makes it easier to pull the right record fast enough, to make sure that the border flows, and is operational" — even though a 2005 Government Accountability Office report found that government RFID readers often failed to detect travelers' tags.

Such assurances don't persuade those who liken RFID-embedded documents to barcodes with antennas and contend they create risks to privacy that far outweigh the technology's heralded benefits. They warn it will actually enable identity thieves, stalkers and other criminals to commit "contactless" crimes against victims who won't immediately know they've been violated.

Neville Pattinson, vice president for government affairs at Gemalto, Inc., a major supplier of microchipped cards, is no RFID basher. He's a board member of the Smart Card Alliance, an RFID industry group, and is serving on the Department of Homeland Security's Data Privacy and Integrity Advisory Committee.

Still, Pattinson has sharply criticized the RFIDs in U.S. driver's licenses and passport cards. In a 2007 article for the Privacy Advisor, a newsletter for privacy professionals, he called them vulnerable "to attacks from hackers, identity thieves and possibly even terrorists."

RFID, he wrote, has a fundamental flaw: Each chip is built to faithfully transmit its unique identifier "in the clear, exposing the tag number to interception during the wireless communication."

Once a tag number is intercepted, "it is relatively easy to directly associate it with an individual," he says. "If this is done, then it is possible to make an entire set of movements posing as somebody else without that person's knowledge."
lobster68w (Founding Member) 02 Aug 09, 21:20Post
If you have a new passport with the chip in it, take a hammer and smash the RFID chip in it. It's not required to be working. I don't know how you would kill the ones in passport cards or other ID's, I'd assume a microwave would burn them.
Down with this sort of thing!
Airfoilsguy (Founding Member) 02 Aug 09, 21:25Post
lobster68w wrote:If you have a new passport with the chip in it, take a hammer and smash the RFID chip in it. It's not required to be working. I don't know how you would kill the ones in passport cards or other ID's, I'd assume a microwave would burn them.



http://www.thinkgeek.com/gadgets/security/910f/?cpg=ab
CO777ER (Database Editor & Founding Member) 02 Aug 09, 21:43Post
Ask Mark to put it in one of these for you. I'm sure it would knock it out.

Image

:))
Mark 02 Aug 09, 22:27Post
I would think one could find a cop that will transmit a short message on his squad car's radio as you hold the chip up to the antenna whip. Don't touch the antenna with your fingers, though.
Commercial aircraft flown in: B712 B722 B732 B734 B737 B738 B741 B742 B744 B752 B753 B762 B772 A310 A318 A319 A320 A321 DC91 DC93 DC94 DC1030 DC1040 F100 MD82 MD83 A223 CR2 CR7 E175
captoveur 02 Aug 09, 22:59Post
Mark wrote:I would think one could find a cop that will transmit a short message on his squad car's radio as you hold the chip up to the antenna whip. Don't touch the antenna with your fingers, though.


Our high powered VHF systems are just about all gone.. I don't think the trunked 800mhz systems have the output the old stuff with the big whippy antennas had.

I think the hammer is the easy solution.
I like my coffee how I like my women: Black, bitter, and preferably fair trade.
Allstarflyer (Database Editor & Founding Member) 02 Aug 09, 23:01Post
Just get a thin, lead-lined box-type device in which to store one's ID, passport, credit cards, etc. and drop it in one's backpack. Too pedantic?
captoveur 02 Aug 09, 23:02Post
Allstarflyer wrote:Just get a thin, lead-lined box-type device in which to store one's ID, passport, credit cards, etc. and drop it in one's backpack. Too pedantic?


Extremely Blackbirdish. Don't forget the matching foil hat.
I like my coffee how I like my women: Black, bitter, and preferably fair trade.
Airfoilsguy (Founding Member) 02 Aug 09, 23:28Post
I once took out a computer monitor with a portable radio once. I was writing something and someone called me and I answered, he screen flickered and the guy next to me asked "did your radio do that?" I said "lets see" but this time I keyed it right next to the screen.

Time to call IT for a new screen :)
 

Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 6 guests

LEFT

RIGHT
CONTENT